Unlawful Police Stops Serving Families Throughout Jacksonville For Over 25 Years

Unlawful Police Stops in Jacksonville

Put Approximately 100 Years of Combined Experience on Your Side Today

Under the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, police must have probable cause to believe there has been a violation of the law to initiate a search. This means that there must be some indication in your driving that you are drunk driving or otherwise breaking the law for the police to validly stop you. Where police have overstepped, a Jacksonville DUI lawyer will move to exclude evidence obtained in the illegal stop. When the court approves the motion, the prosecution usually has no choice but to dismiss the case.

What Is Considered Probable Cause?

For a law enforcement officer to make a lawful police stop, it is vitally important that they have what is known as "probable cause." This simply means that they must have some form of evidence that supports the fact that the driver was breaking the law in some capacity. Contrary to popular belief, officers are not permitted to act on whims whenever they desire.

For example, they can't park outside of bars and wait for a driver to leave. The driver must have exhibited some form of drunkenness before the traffic stop became legal. So what is considered grounds for a traffic stop? Any form of traffic violation, such as speeding, or even a physical issue with the car, such as broken lights. Other grounds for a traffic stop could include body damage to the car, failing to use turn signals, expired license plates or aggressive, unlawful behavior.

Sobriety Checkpoints: Exception to the Rule

As an exception to the rule, police may set up sobriety checkpoints on holidays and special occasions to systematically stop motorists to check for sobriety. The Florida courts have ruled these stops are a valid use of the state power to control drunk driving. That does not mean though that police may stop anyone, anywhere to check sobriety. It must be part of a systematized check where many are stopped routinely. It may not be an isolated instance where a police officer has a hunch you are drunk driving just because you're driving a high performance vehicle or another arbitrary reason.

Unlawful Police Stops

In order for sobriety checkpoints to remain constitutional, law enforcement officials must follow very strict regulations and patterns for stopping cars. For example, police must determine beforehand that they are going to stop every "Nth" vehicle such as every 4th or 5th car. Law enforcement may not stop and question the driver of a vehicle simply because they had a hunch, which is an unfounded suspicion.

Other questions to ask when it comes to DUI checkpoints include: Was the roadblock properly marked? Was a police supervisor at the scene of the checkpoint to approve of how it was being conducted? Did a police supervisor approve of the type and nature of the checkpoint before it was implemented? Was your vehicle detained at length without valid cause?

Continue Reading Read Less

Pick Porter™ for a Free Consultation

We at Problems? Pick Porter!™ are strong defenders of our client's rights when police have randomly stopped them without probable cause. We have been serving the Jacksonville, Florida area with DUI defense. As three former prosecuting attorneys with approximately 100 years pf combined legal experience, we have successfully obtained many dismissals or acquittals of charges when police have infringed on our clients' rights with illegal stops.

We urge you to speak with a Jacksonville DUI attorney at the firm as soon after your arrest as possible.

A Guided, Hands-On Approach
Step-by-Step Guidance for Any Legal Matter
A Compassionate Team
Your Story Matters - We're Here to Listen
Extensive Experience
Approximately 100 Years of Combined Legal Experience On Your Side
Award-Winning Counsel
Top-Rated Ethics & Legal Skill – AV Preeminent® Rating
Trusted & Recommended
Trusted by the Media & Recommended by Our Clients
Top-Rated Attorneys
Top-Rated Personal Injury, DUI, & Criminal Defense Lawyer

Hear From Our Happy Clients

Serving Jacksonville, FL Since 2004

"Franz Bastien I am speechless"
Franz Bastien I am speechless

- P.E.
"Ms. Carlucci provides great support and promotes collaboration with her clients."
My divorce litigated for close to two years as it was highly contentious and involved more complexities. Ms. Carlucci did a wonderful job of helping me understand and navigate the legal system. Ms. Carlucci set realistic expectations and was willing to listen to my concerns, questions, and thoughts. Divorce can be a very grueling and hard process. Ms. Carlucci provides great support and promotes collaboration with her clients.

- Former Client
"Nicely Done! Success has been reached!"
Many times when you meet attorneys to represent you, there are thoughts that reside in the back of your head...some good and some bad. "Are these guys REALLY going to help me," or "do they REALLY have my best interest," or "can I really trust them?" Those are the many thoughts, plus more, that I had--it did go away after my first initial visit with one of the attorney's at Jason's Porter's law office. For my case, I worked with two different attorneys which included Jason Porter himself. Both of those guys were with me 100% from the beginning, in court, after court, late in the evening by phone calls, text, and emails, it was a great experience. What was consistent and what I valued most is that I got to know both of them, what they like to do in their personal time with family, which felt like I could communicate openly and honestly. My case was a criminal case and because of them, I do not have to be viewed as a criminal. I want to share and express my gratitude for how they have helped me so others can choose Jason Porter.

- JW
"10/10 recommend- especially if you don’t want to leave the beach!"
Jason Porter and Nicole Carlucci are the best attorneys in Jax Beach! Listen, no one wants to hire an attorney, but if you need one- these are the people to call. I was able to schedule a same-day appointment and they were professional, courteous, and provided an excellent outcome to my case. 10/10 recommend- especially if you don’t want to leave the beach!

- K.M.
"Will definitely use them in the future if need be."
Retain them you’re in great hands! They will get the job done. Got my case dismissed. Will definitely use them in the future if need be.

- T.R.
"He is our family attorney forever."
There are times when you may need unforeseen legal assistance and your scared and don't have a clue if youre making the right choice. The decision is not an easy one when it's based on your family and life. You worry if they have your best interest at heart, if they know enough, if they know the right people and it's very emotional & confusing. Ten years ago my family was faced with the worst nightmare any mother could ever imagine & I prayed to God to make the right decision and I did. Meeting Jason Porter & his assistant Darlene C. (she's been with him longer than that), was the best in my life in my family's life. Jason doesn't have a big office turn around, in fact I have watched his office grow to the success it is today. His staff stays because they know they are with a terrific guy & great attorney. I can go on and on and mean every word from the bottom of my heart but the are truly no words to describe the great outcomes he has had for 2 of my sons on separate occasions. Unfortunately, we don't live in a society anymore where "boys will be boys". There are way too many laws and not enough of societal morality (due to a change of the times). Boys may get in trouble, they did get in trouble but with their unfortunate choices, my choice was the better in retaining Jason and his law firm. He is our family attorney forever.

- Anonymous
"him and his team have WON EVERY CASE for me"
Best attorney in town him and his team have WON EVERY CASE for me. Jason and his team will fix whatever you may have gotten yourself into. Keep your MOUTH SHUT AND THEN CALL JASON PORTER. YOU WONT REGRET THAT I PROMISE.

- A.H.
"Jason Porter excellent attorney"
Jason Porter is an excellent attorney. I'm very happy with the results. he saved me money and solved my problem.

- John P.

Read Reviews

Pick Porter!™ Today

A member of our team will be in touch shortly to confirm your contact details or address questions you may have.

*Motorcycle accident - $2,835,000
$1,502,500 Premises Liability - $1,502,500
Bodily Injury Claim
*Wrongful Death - $1,000,000
Settled *Estate of Fred Fedorka
Largest settlement ever against Volusia County.
*Medical Malpractice - $500,000

View All Results